How Much Does It Cost to Hire a Car Accident Lawyer in New York?
It usually costs nothing upfront to hire a car accident lawyer in New York because nearly all of them work on a contingency fee, which means you only pay if they win your case. That fee is typically one-third (33⅓%) of your recovery, and it comes out of the settlement at the end.
That’s good news if you’ve been putting off calling a lawyer over cost. Edelman, Krasin & Jaye works on a contingency fee basis, and our Long Island car accident lawyers explain exactly how car accident lawyer fees work before you sign anything, so there are no surprises later.
How Contingency Fees Work
A contingency fee means your lawyer’s payment is contingent on winning your case. Instead of billing by the hour, they take an agreed-upon percentage of whatever they recover for you. If they recover nothing, you owe no attorney’s fee.
In New York personal injury cases, that percentage is most often one-third (33⅓%) of the total recovery. So if your case settles for $90,000, the attorney’s fee would typically be $30,000, leaving the rest for you (minus case costs, which we’ll get to).
This setup exists to let people who could never afford an hourly lawyer still get top-tier representation. It also puts you and your lawyer on the same side, since the firm only does well when you do.
For a free legal consultation, call (800) 469-7429
What a Contingency Fee Does and Doesn’t Cover
The contingency percentage covers the attorney’s fee, but a lawsuit also has case costs, which are separate expenses needed to build your claim. These can include:
- Court filing fees
- Fees for obtaining medical records and police reports
- Payments to expert witnesses, like doctors or accident reconstructionists
- Deposition and court reporter costs
Most firms, including Edelman, Krasin & Jaye, front these costs for you and get reimbursed out of the settlement at the end. The key detail is how they’re deducted.
Fee First or Costs First?
The order matters more than you’d think. Under New York’s attorney fee rules, the contingency fee is typically calculated after case costs are subtracted from the recovery, which usually works in the client’s favor. A reputable firm will spell this out clearly in your retainer agreement, so there are no surprises when the check arrives.
Are There Any Upfront or Hidden Costs?
For the vast majority of New York car accident claims, no, you pay nothing upfront. There’s no hourly bill, no consultation fee at a firm like Edelman, Krasin & Jaye, and no retainer check to write before work begins. A trustworthy lawyer will explain, in writing:
- The exact contingency percentage
- Whether that percentage is taken before or after costs
- What happens to case costs if you lose (at many firms, you owe nothing)
If a lawyer can’t or won’t put those answers in plain language, that’s a red flag. Our team walks every client through the retainer line by line, because an informed client is one who trusts the process.
Click to contact our attorneys today
Why “Free Unless You Win” Actually Benefits You
It’s fair to wonder how paying a third of your settlement is a good deal. The answer comes down to how insurance companies actually operate.
Insurance adjusters are trained to settle claims for as little as possible, and they know exactly how much more leverage they have against someone without legal representation. Without a lawyer, you’re negotiating against a company that handles thousands of these claims a year, while you’ve likely never done it before. That imbalance is where most lowball offers come from.
Put simply, a good car accident lawyer changes that dynamic. They know what a claim is actually worth, how to document it properly, and how to push back when an insurer tries to undervalue it, which is exactly what you’re paying for when you hire one.
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now
How Much Will You Actually Take Home?
This is the question behind the question. Your net recovery depends on three things:
- The total settlement or verdict: the bigger the recovery, the more there is to go around.
- The contingency percentage: usually one-third in New York.
- Case costs and any medical liens: expenses and unpaid medical bills that get settled from your share.
Medical liens are the piece people forget. If your health insurer or a provider paid for treatment, they may be entitled to reimbursement from your settlement. A skilled firm negotiates those liens down, which can meaningfully boost what you actually pocket. That negotiation alone often offsets a chunk of the attorney’s fee.
New York Car Accident Lawyer Cost FAQs
Do I Pay Anything if I Lose My Car Accident Case?
You generally don’t pay attorney’s fees if you lose your car accident case, because contingency fee agreements only pay the lawyer when they recover money for you. At many New York firms, including Edelman, Krasin & Jaye, you also won’t owe the case costs the firm advanced if the case is unsuccessful.
Always confirm this in writing, though. The exact handling of case costs on a loss can vary between firms, so your retainer agreement should state it plainly before you sign.
Is the Contingency Fee Negotiable?
The contingency fee can sometimes be negotiable, though the one-third standard is common across New York personal injury cases. Factors like the complexity of your case or the likelihood of a quick settlement may affect what a firm is willing to agree to.
What matters most is transparency. A firm that clearly explains its fee and what you get for it is often worth more than one offering a slightly lower percentage with vaguer service.
Are Consultations Really Free?
Consultations are genuinely free at most New York car accident firms, including ours, with no obligation to hire anyone afterward. It’s a chance to understand your options and get a professional read on your case before deciding anything.
Use that meeting to ask directly about fees, costs, and timelines. A good lawyer will answer every question without pressure, which also tells you a lot about how they’ll treat you as a client.
Talk to a Local Car Accident Lawyer Today
Now that you know how much it costs to hire a car accident lawyer in New York, the better question is what a strong claim could be worth in your hands versus an insurer’s.
The team at Edelman, Krasin & Jaye offers a free consultation, no strings attached, so you can get honest answers about your case and your options. Reach out today and find out where you stand before you settle for less.
Call or text (800) 469-7429 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form
